Puppet Dallying: Thoughts on Shakespearean Theatricality
Gross, Kenneth.
Review by Lori Hopkins
Kenneth Gross is a Professor of English with a PhD from Yale University. He has published numerous books and essays on a variety of subjects, many featuring a focus on puppets or Shakespeare In his 2009 critical essay, Puppets Dallying: Thoughts on Shakespearean Theatricality, he brings two of his most loved subjects together for close examination. Whilst not an expert of puppetry, his comments and thoughts on the application and existence of puppets in Shakespeare’s language are insightful and highly detailed.
His essay draws on many different definitions and interpretations of the word puppet in Shakespeare’s English language. In A Midsummer Night’s Dream, ‘You puppet!’ is used as a n insult, harking back to a time when a woman in heavy make-up or a prostitute was though of as an immoral puppet or dolly. I find this use of the term puppet to be quite degrading and backward. Surely a figure who takes control of her appearance and makes decisions about her life is a free spirit, not to be compared to an unthinking or feeling doll. In Anthony and Cleopatra, the Egyptian queen warns her Lady Iras not to become a ‘puppet’ in the political backdrop of Rome. A strong reminder to be in control of your own destiny.
Whilst discussing the animation of certain objects within some plays, Gross refers to the personification of an object as if this type of description transforms that object into a puppet. For example, when Hamlet describes his father’s tomb as opening ‘his ponderous and marble jaws’, Gross believes that a puppet world in which objects have a life of their own is being created. This reminds me of old animated Disney cartoons whereby a myriad everyday objects take on a personality and character. Take Beauty and the Beast, where some of the principal characters of the film are a candlestick and a clock. If this concept were to be theatricalised (which indeed it has been), then these characters would have to be played by puppets. However, what Shakespeare is suggesting in Hamlet’s case, is that the illusion of a living object is created only because of Hamlet’s state of mind, not that the objects actually do come to life as they have done in the Disney classic. The necessity for an object to have a puppeteer in order to animate it is reflected here in Shakespeare’s play, because without the influence of the human character’s imagination, the objects would remain lifeless and ordinary.
Gross writes with great passion that ‘Shakespeare’s is a theater preoccupied with giving life to inanimate things . . .’. Although Gross reminds us that there are only ‘perhaps seven or eight references to puppets and puppet theater in the plays of Shakespeare’, I agree that the use of imagery and poetic language have the power to breathe life into a handkerchief, a coin or a crown, thus making these plays a wonderful stimulus for creating puppet theatre. His concern with the human condition and the effect of one person or group of people over another allow for an abundance of visual metaphorical worlds and relationships to be portrayed.
I you would like to read the original essay please contact me and I can send you the file.
ReplyDelete