Essay review:
The Cocreation of the Comic in Puppetry
by Frank Proschan in Sherzer and Sherzer, Humor and Comedy in Puppetry. Bowling Green Press: Ohio, 1987.
Frank Proschan’s essay concerns the role of
the spectator in creating comedy in puppet theatre. He refers to the ‘cocreation'
of meaning in terms of the participation of audiences and their ability to
interpret signs. His statement, “every traditional puppetry performance is a
collaboration between puppeteer and audience”, raises questions about the
difference between puppet theatre and straight or human theatre. One could
argue that in order for theatre to exist, you need a space, and audience and a
performer. Therefore for any performance to exist whether puppetry, dance, live
art, anything at all, there must be a level of collaboration. What Proschan
states is that different genres have different rules and requirements about the
degrees to which a spectator should participate in a performance and the ways
in which that participation is expressed. Some of what he says feels somewhat
irrelevant in today’s cross-genre, mixed-form theatre environment. Nowadays I
feel that the way in which an audience member collaborates in a performance is
more likely to be unique to each performance rather than to each genre of
performance. Within one contemporary puppetry show you may see a range of types
of puppet, combined with music, or projection, possibly using human actors as
well. Therefore an audience is unlikely to sustain a particular level of
participation throughout one performance.
In this essay, Proschan mentions numerous
ways in which puppets and their audience’s can create comedy. He speaks of
scale, language, violence, parody, racism, obscenity and sex, but to name a
few. He then attempts to explain the role that the audience has to play in
helping to create comedy from that element. Looking at violence, for example,
Proschan refers to a shared understanding of a particular sign system that an
audience must first recognize and secondly response to in the manner in which
they are expected. In Punch and Judy shows, a well-versed audience member will
instantly recognize the various characters and props and be able to respond
correctly to vocal prompts, thus he/she is instrumental in creating the comedy.
Going back to my earlier point about how this essay may be slightly less
relevant in our current climate, Proschan’s argument seems only to relate to
very traditional forms. However, I believe he is correct in suggesting that an
audience that can relate to the sign system in use will get more enjoyment from
a performance. For example, Barry Purvis’ animation Next (1989), uses a series of images and signs based on events that occur in
Shakespeare plays. If someone has no knowledge of any of the plays, they will
have little understanding or appreciation on the video. Some elements could be
considered universal, or semi-universal. Slapstick humour may make an audience
of mixed ages, backgrounds, cultures laugh out loud as there is no language
barrier, and no understanding of traditional theatre to appreciate the humour.
Proschan talks about the necessity of the
puppet performer to ‘push’ or ‘coerce’ the audience to react in the manner in
which they are supposed to, in relation to the particular storyline. This
allows the spectator to become involved in the show, and have ownership and
cocreation without actually determining the direction of the narrative. He uses
four titles to define audience participation: Investor, Instigator, Definer and
Ratifier. These definitions cover
the range of ways in which one can participate, including vocal response to
questions asked by a puppet, naming an object or character, being arranged by
the puppeteer before the show even begins and given a role in the show and so
on.
Although there are many fascinating ideas
that elevate the importance of audiences and allows us to consider their role
in creating comedy n traditional forms, I believe that some of Proschan’s
arguments are irrelevant in the vast and varied world of modern puppet and
alternative theatre. In terms of dissecting Punch and Judy shows, this essay is
extremely useful.