Monday, 6 August 2012

The Cocreation of the Comic in Puppetry

 
Essay review: 

The Cocreation of the Comic in Puppetry by Frank Proschan in Sherzer and Sherzer, Humor and Comedy in Puppetry. Bowling Green Press: Ohio, 1987.


Frank Proschan’s essay concerns the role of the spectator in creating comedy in puppet theatre. He refers to the ‘cocreation' of meaning in terms of the participation of audiences and their ability to interpret signs. His statement, “every traditional puppetry performance is a collaboration between puppeteer and audience”, raises questions about the difference between puppet theatre and straight or human theatre. One could argue that in order for theatre to exist, you need a space, and audience and a performer. Therefore for any performance to exist whether puppetry, dance, live art, anything at all, there must be a level of collaboration. What Proschan states is that different genres have different rules and requirements about the degrees to which a spectator should participate in a performance and the ways in which that participation is expressed. Some of what he says feels somewhat irrelevant in today’s cross-genre, mixed-form theatre environment. Nowadays I feel that the way in which an audience member collaborates in a performance is more likely to be unique to each performance rather than to each genre of performance. Within one contemporary puppetry show you may see a range of types of puppet, combined with music, or projection, possibly using human actors as well. Therefore an audience is unlikely to sustain a particular level of participation throughout one performance.

In this essay, Proschan mentions numerous ways in which puppets and their audience’s can create comedy. He speaks of scale, language, violence, parody, racism, obscenity and sex, but to name a few. He then attempts to explain the role that the audience has to play in helping to create comedy from that element. Looking at violence, for example, Proschan refers to a shared understanding of a particular sign system that an audience must first recognize and secondly response to in the manner in which they are expected. In Punch and Judy shows, a well-versed audience member will instantly recognize the various characters and props and be able to respond correctly to vocal prompts, thus he/she is instrumental in creating the comedy. Going back to my earlier point about how this essay may be slightly less relevant in our current climate, Proschan’s argument seems only to relate to very traditional forms. However, I believe he is correct in suggesting that an audience that can relate to the sign system in use will get more enjoyment from a performance. For example, Barry Purvis’ animation Next (1989), uses a series of images and signs based on events that occur in Shakespeare plays. If someone has no knowledge of any of the plays, they will have little understanding or appreciation on the video. Some elements could be considered universal, or semi-universal. Slapstick humour may make an audience of mixed ages, backgrounds, cultures laugh out loud as there is no language barrier, and no understanding of traditional theatre to appreciate the humour.

Proschan talks about the necessity of the puppet performer to ‘push’ or ‘coerce’ the audience to react in the manner in which they are supposed to, in relation to the particular storyline. This allows the spectator to become involved in the show, and have ownership and cocreation without actually determining the direction of the narrative. He uses four titles to define audience participation: Investor, Instigator, Definer and Ratifier.  These definitions cover the range of ways in which one can participate, including vocal response to questions asked by a puppet, naming an object or character, being arranged by the puppeteer before the show even begins and given a role in the show and so on.

Although there are many fascinating ideas that elevate the importance of audiences and allows us to consider their role in creating comedy n traditional forms, I believe that some of Proschan’s arguments are irrelevant in the vast and varied world of modern puppet and alternative theatre. In terms of dissecting Punch and Judy shows, this essay is extremely useful.


Sunday, 15 July 2012

Review of The Seas of Organillo by Stephen Mottram's Animata

A small round, open-topped booth, softly illuminated sits atop a blacked stage. Old-fashioned organ music conjures images of vintage fairgrounds and circus folk. A semi-mechanical marionette boat containing two figures drifts around the booth, controlled by the ever-present Stephen Mottram. This boat and it’s occupants are the first of a series of moments, presented to the audience on the theme of fertility, but set in a science-fiction, underwater, alien world.

The basic premise of this alien environment is that “the dark, salty water of the ancient seas represent the mysterious, amniotic interior in which we all started life”. We see orbs, symbolic of eggs and fish with sperm-like movement jerking an moving towards their goal. Each exquisitely crafted puppet has a unique style of movement, enhanced by motors and clever technique. Mottram’s operating of the puppets appears effortless producing graceful, smooth movement truly evocative of the deep recesses of an ocean. Using several “tricks” we see figures that blow bubbles, fish that seem to multiply, a clam with an enormous appetite, orbs that move with no contact from the puppeteer and much more. This show features such a high quality of technical dexterity and wizardry that the viewer can almost forgive the slow and at times undramatic nature of the performance.

Thanks to the superb lighting, each scene presented has an absolute clarity of visual image, the puppets contrasting well against the black backdrops. Their shadows fall on side flats suggesting a three-dimensional space and dense atmosphere. Mottram’s presence adds an extra level of depth to the piece. He appears as a creator, a conjuror, influencing events and affecting change. The combination of hands-on puppetry, and automated objects that have a life of their own works fantastically well as both share a fluid and cyclic quality of movement.

This show is quietly erotic and invokes images of birth, death, sex, and eventually comes full circle as the boat returns, but this time a small baby in a bubble follows behind. Interestingly, however, this performance began life as a musical commission. Mottram was asked to create a piece of music and a series of pictures. He has built an organillo -  a small music box with a handle that is turned to produce melody. At the close of the show he demonstrated this ingenious device to the audience, explained how he came about making it and finally we understood that the soundtrack to The Seas of Organillo is almost entirely composed of sounds generated by the organillo, from the grinding of the handle, to the squeak of the bellows.

There is no linear narrative and yet this show tells a story larger than the microcosm that we are presented with, the story of fertilisation. Mottram delivers an intense, slick and captivating performance where he appears, much like the Wizard of Oz, making his magic and creating illusions behind the curtain where we are allowed to witness some and yet not all of the genius behind his automata.

Beverley Puppet Festival 2012

 

Following a much-delayed journey with unnecessary train changes and a lack of working toilets, I arrived in Beverley for the first time. The sun was not shining. No surprise there, however there was a definite festival aura surrounding the town centre. My first stop was the festival hubsite at the Friary gardens; small yet atmospheric, with tents, tables, a bar, a puppet caravan and even a booksale, (that left me agonising over spending my pennies on both vintage and brand new titles). Showers had scared some of the punters away, however the hardy folk who had stuck around had plenty to keep them entertained.

There has been an excellent range of free performances this year to suit all ages. Professor Popup of Nottingham, playing Farmer Jolly had a small fanclub, fixated by his beautifully carved hen marionette amongst others. His highly interactive walkabout, as always, showcased his skill not only as an operator but also in his ability to charm and engage a younger crowd. Little Fawn of Glasgow had constructed their upcycled caravan and were showing two very different performances. I caught Weasel in Love on Sunday afternoon and adored the intimate space, use of props and stripped down nature of this show. I also heard great reviews of the dark,Saturday show, Sleep Crawling. Shane of Little Fawn was kind enough to show me backstage and explained the technical aspects of the caravan theatre.

On walkabouts through the town were a variety of acts including Cusan Productions’ vibrant and engaging Latin Horses and Walking Tall’s Giant Punch and Judy.

 Latin Horses by Cusan Productions

The sunshine finally made an appearance on Sunday morning and as a lone adult visitor to the festival I had to spend some of my time battling the hoards of children and families to get a good view of all the free theatre on show! One such instance, was to get a good seat on the grass in the Friary Gardens to watch Noisy Oyster’s Plain Bob. Although I saw the debut of this particular show at Skipton last year, I was eager to repeat the experience. For me, Plain Bob captures the essence of festival theatre, springing up from suitcases and using a variety of simple yet effective scenic elements and props, plus some audience interaction aimed at pleasing the adults as well as the younger faces. The small rod puppets are almost magical, and using some technical wizardry, there is a delightful surprise at the end. 

 Plain Bob by Noisy Oyster

There was plenty to entertain the children at the hubsite, with puppet-making workshops, a variety of Punch and Judy shows and Cath Conolly of Nottingham’s Marvellous Mouse Circus. The quality of the adult puppetry on offer was also extremely high. You can read my reviews of two performances very soon:

Spirit by Sue Beattie Company

The Seas of Organillo by Stephen Mottram’s Animata

 Anna Ingleby, festival organiser was a strong presence at this festival, popping up at each show and begging for new members to join the committee, the facebook group and to fill out evaluation forms to ensure that funding continues in the future. Beverley is now the largest festival of UK puppetry in the world. I can’t imagine how much work must go into organising such a huge biennial event and I do hope that 2014 will match the success of this year. Well done to all performers, volunteers, partners and audiences!

Sunday, 1 July 2012

 
Book Review of Puppetry: A Reader in Theatre Practice by Penny Francis

(Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012)

With puppetry undergoing a massive resurgence in mainstream theatre and rising in popularity for adult audiences thanks to the vibrant festival scene and growing educational opportunities in the UK, Penny Francis has written this excellent ‘reader’ at the perfect time. This is a book for students of puppetry, avid fans and theatre professionals and is thus written in a practical, intelligent and coherent fashion.


Francis opens by exploring the concept of ‘puppet’; it’s origins, signification and cultural placement. She places the puppet in a 21st century context by debating the possibility of defining modern technologies, (CGI, avatars and the suchlike) as puppets, drawing on a range of existing theory and writing on the subject. Of course it is impossible to think of the puppet without also musing on the role of the puppeteer and Francis helps to clarify and expand on this.

Following a thorough introduction, this book goes on to discuss the related arts of mask, ventriloquism and automata in some detail, particularly useful to those considering cross-media theatre practice. Her chapter on Techniques is highly informative and sets out in a clear and understandable manner the various ‘categories’ of puppet types. Even a complete novice in the field would be able to read and then have a good knowledge of how different puppets are made, operated and how one might select what type of puppet could be used for what purpose.


What makes this book stand apart from other similar publications that have come before is the depth Francis goes into when discussing puppetry as a theatrical practice. She dedicates an entire chapter to the many other elements needed to create a puppet performance including, directing, writing, sound and lighting. This particular section serves as a reminder and guidebook for anyone wanting to create performance that has failed to think about the mise en scene and dramaturgy as a whole. It is also useful again, for those who are thinking about collaborative work, or multimedia performance.

Francis’ use of quotes throughout the book is excellent and she draws the reader’s attention to some of the most celebrated authors on puppetry and thinkers on theatre. A highlight is her chapter on Aesthetics, where she includes a number of essays giving a range of thought-provoking discussions, ideas and debates. Rather usefully, she also provides a ‘Further Reading’ list at the end of each chapter to point the reader to alternative publications in order to expand their reading on a particular subject area.

The book closes with a concise history of puppet theatre up to the present day, where a rich and colourful past is painted. Francis cleverly places puppetry within the global context of theatre not as a separate entity.

Puppetry: A Reader in Theatre Practice is an informative, well-written and thorough analysis of the art form and is sure to be a must-have for any student of puppetry. Francis’ choice of images, references and personal anecdotes is perfect and her writing engaging and thoughtful.

Sunday, 25 March 2012

Review of David Currell's 'Learning With Puppets'

 If you were to judge this book by its cover you may decide that it is dated, and feel that you can most likely find a more recently published book with more useful and relevant information. However, like most of David Currell’s books, Learning with Puppets is full of practical and vital information for puppeteers. Some makers may find that they know of some newer, alternative materials or that due to technological advancements some of the lighting and sound suggestions could be slightly out-of-date, however on the whole this book provides a great resource for anyone working on a budget or with simple materials and methods.    

As a puppeteer currently working in the educational field, this book is of particular interest to me as it not only contains some simple puppet designs for working with children and young people, but also has actual lesson plans for complete educational projects that can be adapted and interpreted for your own work. The lesson plans are written from real-life experiences and demonstrate strong links with the curriculum so with a little tweaking could provide the basis for foundations of an educational project. I used the Noah’s Ark lesson plan as inspiration for a shadow puppetry project with a Key Stage 2 art club and found Currell’s suggestions extremely useful. Rather than being a step-by-step instruction manual, his lesson plans instead act as an inspiration point.

What really strikes me with Currell’s insight is that he makes constant reference to the uses of puppetry in the classroom, not primarily as a tool for developing puppetry skills, but the other physical and mental skills in can aid. He gives clear examples of how puppetry can aid development in literacy, numeracy, humanities, art and design and motor skills. My concern would be that a teacher using this book as a resource for taking puppetry into the classroom would lack the skills of a puppeteer to be able to carry out the projects successfully. I don’t believe that you can acquire the necessary knowledge to be a puppet educator simply from reading a book, however good that book might be!

Learning with Puppets is well illustrated to help explain certain concepts. His section on ‘Proportions for a puppet’ is made far more comprehensible because of his simple black and white diagrams. His shadow puppet construction diagrams were a huge help to me when I was learning to design and make articulated figures. I have not yet had a chance to experiment with some of his other puppet making styles and would love to hear from anyone who has tried them out.

Overall Currell’s book is a fantastic practical guide and with perhaps a few updates to bring it into the twenty-first century should be an essential purchase for any puppeteers working in Primary or Secondary school settings.

Currell, David. Learning With Puppets. (London: Ward Lock Educational, 1980).

Saturday, 24 March 2012

Puppets Dallying: essay review

 
Puppet Dallying: Thoughts on Shakespearean Theatricality
Gross, Kenneth.

Review by Lori Hopkins

Kenneth Gross is a Professor of English with a PhD from Yale University. He has published numerous books and essays on a variety of subjects, many featuring a focus on puppets or Shakespeare In his 2009 critical essay, Puppets Dallying: Thoughts on Shakespearean Theatricality, he brings two of his most loved subjects together for close examination. Whilst not an expert of puppetry, his comments and thoughts on the application and existence of puppets in Shakespeare’s language are insightful and highly detailed.

His essay draws on many different definitions and interpretations of the word puppet in Shakespeare’s English language. In A Midsummer Night’s Dream, ‘You puppet!’ is used as a n insult, harking back to a time when a woman in heavy make-up or a prostitute was though of as an immoral puppet or dolly. I find this use of the term puppet to be quite degrading and backward. Surely a figure who takes control of her appearance and makes decisions about her life is a free spirit, not to be compared to an unthinking or feeling doll. In Anthony and Cleopatra, the Egyptian queen warns her Lady Iras not to become a ‘puppet’ in the political backdrop of Rome. A strong reminder to be in control of your own destiny.

Whilst discussing the animation of certain objects within some plays, Gross refers to the personification of an object as if this type of description transforms that object into a puppet. For example, when Hamlet describes his father’s tomb as opening ‘his ponderous and marble jaws’, Gross believes that a puppet world in which objects have a life of their own is being created. This reminds me of old animated Disney cartoons whereby a myriad everyday objects take on a personality and character. Take Beauty and the Beast, where some of the principal characters of the film are a candlestick and a clock. If this concept were to be theatricalised (which indeed it has been), then these characters would have to be played by puppets. However, what Shakespeare is suggesting in Hamlet’s case, is that the illusion of a living object is created only because of Hamlet’s state of mind, not that the objects actually do come to life as they have done in the Disney classic. The necessity for an object to have a puppeteer in order to animate it is reflected here in Shakespeare’s play, because without the influence of the human character’s imagination, the objects would remain lifeless and ordinary.

Gross writes with great passion that ‘Shakespeare’s is a theater preoccupied with giving life to inanimate things . . .’. Although Gross reminds us that there are only ‘perhaps seven or eight references to puppets and puppet theater in the plays of Shakespeare’, I agree that the use of imagery and poetic language have the power to breathe life into a handkerchief, a coin or a crown, thus making these plays a wonderful stimulus for creating puppet theatre. His concern with the human condition and the effect of one person or group of people over another allow for an abundance of visual metaphorical worlds and relationships to be portrayed.